Histologic features of idiopathic noncirrhotic portal hypertension (INCPH), loosely termed as obliterative portal venopathy (OPV), are heterogenous, often subtle, and overlap with other entities. To this date, no consensus histopathologic diagnostic criteria have been established for INCPH. For these reasons, rendering a reproducible consensus histologic diagnosis of OPV on a liver biopsy may often be challenging even for experienced hepatopathologists. We report herein a two-phase interobserver agreement study on the diagnosis of OPV and assessed the relative value of histologic features in 104 liver biopsies in distinguishing between INCPH and non-INCPH with the goal to obtain a consensus on specific practical diagnostic criteria. Six hepatopathologists blinded to clinical information and original pathologic diagnosis reviewed internet-based case study sets with high-resolution whole-slide images. The initial interobserver agreement on OPV was expectedly low, but significantly improved (moderate agreement in most categories) upon adopting a consensus view recognizing portal vein sclerosis as the only strong independent histologic predictor for INCPH, and that contrary to the conventional view, aberrant portal/periportal vessels does not significantly contribute to the positive assignment of OPV status. We propose a three-tiered classification with diagnostic criteria to facilitate the histologic assignment of OPV status for the evaluation of INCPH. Furthermore, we have validated the performance of the proposed criteria either based on histology alone or coupled with clinicopathologic correlation. This classification may aid in practical histologic assessment of liver biopsies with or without portal hypertension and help to improve diagnostic consistency and accuracy.