Fibroma of tendon sheath (FTS) is an uncommon benign myofibroblastic neoplasm that arises in association with tenosynovial tissue. Fusions of the USP6 gene have been recently documented in a proportion of so-called "cellular FTS" but not in "classic FTS". It remains unknown whether FTS can be defined by a USP6 fusion, regardless of cellularity, and what are USP6 fusion-negative "cellular FTS". Furthermore, FTS with low cellularity seems to be frequently confused with desmoplastic fibroblastoma. We performed a comprehensive analysis, including targeted RNA sequencing, of 58 consecutive cases originally diagnosed as FTS (n = 49), desmoplastic fibroblastoma (n = 6), or nodular fasciitis (n = 3); the latter two at the predilection sites for FTS. After review of the original slides, 28 lesions were morphologically classified as FTS (13 "classic" and 15 "cellular") and 23 as desmoplastic fibroblastoma. Among originally diagnosed FTS at the more cellular end of the spectrum, we identified seven lesions that shared many morphologic features of FTS but, in addition, showed several distinct morphologic features consistent with myofibroma, such as myoid appearance, branching thin-walled vessels, and perivascular growth. Targeted RNA sequencing showed a USP6 fusion in 17 of 18 analyzed FTS, regardless of cellularity, 0 of 5 desmoplastic fibroblastomas and 0 of 4 myofibromas. MYH9, COL1A1, and ASPN were identified as fusion partners in three cases each, and MIR22HG, CTNNB1, SPARC, CAP1, EMP1, LINC00152, NR1D1, and RAB1A in a single case each. FTS, regardless of cellularity, can be defined by a USP6 fusion with a variety of fusion partners. More cellular lesions exhibiting some morphologic features of FTS but lacking a USP6 fusion tend to be myofibromas.